EdTech Products Supporting ELL

Apps & Mobile, EdLeaders, EdTech, Leadership, Learning, Online & Blended

Globalization means more interaction between native speakers of different languages. Continued immigration to the U.S. means more people that need to learn English. Both are served by the expansion of mobile access, the explosion of EdApps, and the rise of machine learning. EdTech investments of $3 billion last year resulted in improvements to hundreds of reading and writing apps and products specifically created for English Language Learners (ELL).

We spent the last month reviewing about a hundred programs and apps in 17 categories. The first eight categories reflect the general trend toward personalized learning, an extremely important benefit to ELL and all students with learning differences (i.e., most of them).

ELA Products, ELL Supports Common Use Examples Innovation Opportunity

Adaptive reading

Elementary supplement with ELL supports

i-Ready, iStation, Imagine Learning, Achieve3000, LightSail

More content and subjects

Leveled readers

Intermediate/middle grade supplement

Accelerated Reader, Lexia, Curriculet, Newsela, MyOn

More titles including open content, better recommendations

ELA & math courses with ELL supports

Core secondary curriculum with supports

Apex Learning, Fuel Education, Connections,  HMH, Edgenuity, GreatMinds, PreK12Plaza

Personalized supports

ELA lessons with ELL supports

Open curriculum resources with ELL adaptations

Achieve the Core, EL Education, EngageNY, BetterLesson, LDC, ThinkCerca, LearnZillion, Pinterest, Quill

Platform integration with learner profiles, teacher coaching

Literacy tools with ELL supports

Digital reading and writing tools

OneNote Learning Tools

Vocabulary & content videos

K-12 ELA & subject supplement

BrainPOP, Flocabulary, Study Island, Khan Academy

Personalized adaptive playlists

Writing feedback

Core secondary curriculum support

PEG, WriteToLearn, Lightside, WriteLab

Text-to-Speech, feedback translation, better UX

Reading Intervention

Secondary double block

Read 180, Achieve3000

Personalized supports

 

The next 6 categories are tools specifically focused on ELL teachers and students. Example and remaining innovation opportunities are summarized below.

 

ELL Products

Common Use

Examples

Innovation Opportunity

ELL management

Program management, communication, reporting

ELLevation, e-ELL PRO, eStar ELL

Include/link to all other categories; mobile progress monitoring

ELL courseware

Secondary double block

ELLoquence, Learning Upgrade, Lingual Learning, Rosetta Stone, Middlebury, HMH

Adaptive assessment and supports

ELL listening

Informal, supplemental

EnglishPodcast, Listen & Speak, Learn English Elementary

(Android apps)

Full text and support

ELL assessments

Track progress

Pearson TELL, WIDA

Instruction embedded

ELL conversations

Speak with native speakers

Busuu, WeSpeke

K-12 use with vetted mentors

ELL PD

Technical assistance, coaching, PD, PLC

Confianza, Lingual Learning, VIF, Edmodo

Links to resources, micro-credentials

 

We also considered several general categories highly relevant to ELL.

 

ELA Relevant Products

Common Use

Examples

Innovation Opportunity

Adaptive math

K-12 supplement

ALEKS, Dreambox, Reasoning Mind, ST Math, Knewton

Supports in multiple languages

Communication

K-12 parent communication with translation

Class DoJo, Remind, TalkingPoints, Google translate

Integration with learning platforms

Learning assistant

Image/voice  recognition, content linking

Volley, Siri, Cortana

Links to profile, adaptive

The last category, personalized learning assistants, is new and promising for all learners. Rapid progress in artificial intelligence (and specifically the categories discussed below) means that all learners will soon benefit from a customized course of study informed by a comprehensive learner profile–and, if we do this right, motivated and supported by teachers in rich learning environments.

Technologies with the potential to improve ELL support

To identify impact impact opportunities it’s helpful to take a quick dive into the underlying technologies behind these product categories and look at the status of the technology (i.e., in basic research, in applied research, used in product development, or mature)and its current level of adoption.

Natural language processing (NLP)

  • Machine learning applications seeking to extract meaning from text
  • Applications: translation, writing feedback, speech recognition, natural language generation, question answering, information retrieval
  • Uses: writing feedback/scoring systems have been used for 15 years but are not widely adopted
  • Potential use: conversation agent that can detect/promote levels of understanding; feedback on constructed response (untrained data)
  • Impact potential: very high
  • Stage: applied research & product development

Other Machine learning (ML)

  • Algorithms that learn from and make predictions on data
  • Applications: Assess and recommend optimal development pathways by learner type; determine the most efficient practice schedule and content for each learner
  • Use: adaptive assessment, reading and math systems (widely adopted)
  • Impact potential: high
  • Stage: adaptive products are mature and widely adopted in blended deployment models; other ML apps are in applied research and product development

Voice recognition (VR)

  • Speech recognition understands voice commands; digital voice signal processing detects proper/improper pronunciation
  • Use: reading instruction, conversation with a smart agent
  • Impact potential: moderate
  • Stage: widely used as a search aid (e.g., Siri); other apps in research or development

Computer vision (CV)

  • Image and facial recognition
  • Use: ability for a computer to read a passage or recognize an image and provide and to translate it into speech in several languages and/or provide several relevant content links
  • Impact potential: moderate
  • Use: personal learning assistant when combined with camera, ML (Volley)

Augmented reality (AR)

  • Live view augmented by computer information via mobile or headset
  • Use: when combined with CV, ML, and NLP, could recognize objects, provide contextual conversation  
  • Impact potential: moderate
  • Stage: applied research, product development

Virtual reality (VR)

  • Immersive environments requiring headset
  • Use: learning environments that with NLP and ML could provide full conversation support
  • Impact potential: moderate
  • Stage: applied research, product development

Learner profile (LP)

  • Comprehensive record of progress and related learning factors (assessment results, motivational preferences, special challenges)
  • Use: will inform every technology listed here and will provide recommendations to teachers
  • Impact potential: high (for all students)
  • Stage: applied research, will require industry standard(s) on assessment integration (see summary)

Telepresence

  • Video conferencing with chat and content sharing often combined with distributed workforce  strategies
  • Use: tutoring and speech therapy (PresenceLearning)
  • Impact potential: moderate

Automated assessment

  • Automated assessment scoring, can be used to drive adaptive sequences
  • Use: combine with standards (for reading, writing, speaking and listening) and teacher scored performance assessments to form micro-credential/badge sequences in competency-based systems
  • Impact potential: moderate (full competency-based progressions that link formal and informal learning offer moderately high potential)

Translation

  • Automated language translation
  • Use: student support in content-based learning; parent communication
  • Impact potential: moderate
  • Stage: widely used in parent communication; some new apps in product development

Social media

  • Platforms that connect and promote content sharing among groups and individuals  
  • Use: live, video, and text conversation with native speakers; professional learning communities for educators
  • Impact potential: moderate
  • Stage: widely used

Conclusion

Like all students, English language learners are benefiting from better access to technology,  personalization tools, and blended learning models. They will also benefit from the longer transition to competency-based education where they progress based on demonstrated mastery. While progress has been steady, there remains an adoption gap, a standards gap, and an invention gap that must be addressed.

Adoption gap: writing feedback systems have steadily improved over the last 15 years but are not widely adopted as a result of poor user experience, weak access to technology and teacher skepticism about computer scoring. The dramatic improvement in secondary student access to technology suggests that demand aggregation strategies would be timely and effective. Pilot projects in high ELL districts would demonstrate use cases and product efficacy. Documenting use cases, conducting efficacy studies and providing adoption incentives would all be productive.  

Standards gap: The sector needs a common method for combining formative assessment to verify progress in language acquisition. Like world languages (i.e., spanish speaking students earning AP credit), ELL is a perfect entry point for competency-based learning. A badge sequence based on multiple forms of assessment would be useful and would encourage extended learning opportunities.

Invention gap: The biggest opportunity in language acquisition is a smart personal agent, one that combines machine learning, natural language processing, computer vision, and voice recognition to provide live feedback on conversation (regarding vocabulary, pronunciation, and grammar) and six trait writing feedback. This EdApp would combine several of the product categories above and could be used across the curriculum and in support of informal learning.

Growing commitment to dual language fluency demands increased investment in dual language tools and content.

This blog is part of the Supporting English Language Learners Series with support from The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. For more, stay tuned for the culminating podcast, infographic and publication.

For more see:


Stay in-the-know with all things EdTech and innovations in learning by signing up to receive the weekly Smart Update. This post includes mentions of a Getting Smart partner. For a full list of partners, affiliate organizations and all other disclosures please see our Partner page.

Tom Vander Ark

Tom Vander Ark

Tom Vander Ark is author of Smart Parents, Smart Cities and Getting Smart. He is co-founder of Getting Smart and Learn Capital and serves on the boards of 4.0 Schools, eduInnovation, Digital Learning Institute, Imagination Foundation, Charter Board Partners and Bloomboard. Follow Tom on Twitter, @tvanderark.

1 Comments

Tom Vander Ark /

Also see iLit ELL, a grades 3-10 reading intervention program, built to support Newcomers to Long Term ELL’s with embedded SIOP notes, translation into 45 languages, integration of the ELPS and a library or 3000 books that goes to Below Reader.